Can a Topped Douglas Fir Be Fixed?
Project Objective: Advise on a large backyard Douglas-fir that had been topped twice by previous owners
Location: Greater Victoria
Service: Tree assessment and pruning advice
Date: November 2026


Tree Service Job Overview
The Request
A homeowner asked for a quote and some advice about the big Douglas-fir in their backyard. They'd been told it had been topped twice in the past, close to the middle of the tree. Their questions were direct. Is topping harmful? Is it illegal for this kind of tree? And is there a 25 percent limit on pruning?
Good questions, and we hear a version of them often. Dozens of the enquiries we get ask us to top a tree. Here's the honest answer, and what careful tree pruning can and can't do afterwards.
Is Topping Harmful?
Yes. Cutting the top out of a conifer leaves a large wound the tree can't seal, and decay starts working down the trunk from there. The tree responds by turning several side branches upward to replace the lost leader. Those new tops grow fast, and they're attached to the outside of the stem just above the decaying cut. Years later they are the part most likely to fail in a storm.
So topping doesn't make a tree safer. It trades a healthy top for a weaker one.
Is It Illegal?
That depends on the municipality and the size of the tree. In Saanich, for example, a Douglas-fir 30 cm or more in diameter is protected. The bylaw says topping is not sound arboricultural practice, and removing the top of a protected tree or more than 25 percent of its live crown in a year counts as altering it, which needs a permit. So the 25 percent figure is real. It isn't a target. It's the line where ordinary pruning ends. Our tree permits and bylaws page covers the other municipalities.
The one opening the Saanich bylaw leaves is re-topping a tree that was already topped, where that's needed to manage a hazard.
What We'd Look At
A topped tree needs a hands-on tree health inspection, not a look from the lawn.
- The old cuts. A climber checks each topping point for decay and how far down it goes.
- The replacement tops. How many, how big, and how well attached?
- What's below. A house, a deck, a neighbour's yard?
SEE RELATED: Removing Hung-Up Limbs and Cabling Douglas Firs in Gordon Head
The Options
If the old cuts are sound and the new tops are small, the answer may be to leave it and check it every couple of years. If the regrowth is large and poorly attached, those tops can be reduced in a controlled way. That's managing damage already done, not topping it again for looks. And if decay is well down the trunk above a target, tree removal with a permit may be the honest advice.
Bought a House With a Topped Tree?
We'll take a close look at the old cuts and tell you plainly what the tree needs, and what it doesn't.
Or call 250-508-4445

Tree care services we can assist with
The Advantage Tree Care team of experienced, ISA arborists is here and ready for action. You can be assured that you and your trees are in the best of hands.
All tree service projects begin with a consultation and site review. Depending on whether it's tree pruning, removals, emergency tree work, or a tree health inspection, we will meet with you to discuss the requirements.
So if you have a project in Victoria, Saanich, Langford, North Saanich, or Sidney, the team over here at Advantage Tree Care would be happy to provide you with a quote. Contact us for a quote, or call 250-508-4445.
Tree Care Portfolio
See all tree care projects. Navigate to a project to learn more.
Can a Topped Douglas Fir Be Fixed?
Can a Topped Douglas Fir Be Fixed? Project Objective: Advise on a large backyard Douglas-fir that had been topped twice by previous ownersLocation: Greater VictoriaService: Tree assessment […]
Bringing a Neglected Heritage Orchard Back Within Reach
Bringing a Neglected Heritage Orchard Back Within Reach Project Objective: Bring overgrown fig, apple, cherry and pear trees at an 1890s home back to a height where […]
Why One Section of a Cedar Hedge Turned Brown
Why One Section of a Cedar Hedge Turned Brown Project Objective: Find out why one stretch of a mature western red cedar hedge browned and didn’t recoverLocation: […]
Removing Hung-Up Limbs and Cabling Douglas Firs in Gordon Head
Removing Hung-Up Limbs and Cabling Douglas Firs in Gordon Head Project Objective: Remove two broken limbs caught in the canopy of large Douglas-firs and install a support […]
Removing Ivy From a Mature Fir in Two Stages
Removing Ivy From a Mature Fir in Two Stages Project Objective: Free a tall backyard fir from ivy so its health could be properly assessedLocation: Greater VictoriaService: […]
Pruning Protected Garry Oaks to Keep Squirrels Off a Roof in Saanich
Pruning Protected Garry Oaks to Keep Squirrels Off a Roof in Saanich Project Objective: Cut off the squirrels’ route to the roof without needing a tree permitLocation: […]
Assessing Two Garry Oaks After a Limb Fell on a Windless Night
Assessing Two Garry Oaks After a Limb Fell on a Windless Night Project Objective: Assess two Garry oaks after a large limb failed without warningLocation: Greater VictoriaService: […]
Diagnosing a Garry Oak That Turned Brown in a Week
Diagnosing a Garry Oak That Turned Brown in a Week Project Objective: Find out why a Garry oak browned suddenly, and if it can be savedLocation: Greater […]
Addressing Tree Fungus and Rot in a Garry Oak in Fernwood, Victoria
Addressing Tree Fungus and Rot in a Garry Oak in Fernwood, Victoria Project Objective: Addressing Tree Fungus and Rot in a Garry Oak Location: Fernwood, Victoria Date: […]
Selective Pruning for a Seaside Property in James Bay Victoria
Selective Pruning for a Seaside Property in James Bay Victoria Project Objective: Selective Pruning job at a Property in James Bay, Victoria Location: Victoria, BC Date: June […]
Treating Impact Wounds and Preventing Decay in a Cedar Tree
Treating Impact Wounds and Preventing Decay in a Cedar Tree Project Objective: Treating Impact Wounds and Preventing Decay in a Cedar Tree Location: Victoria, BC Date: Sept […]
Protecting a Maple Tree from Pests Using Tanglefoot Insect Barrier in Oaklands
Protecting a Fruit Tree from Winter Moth Using Tanglefoot Insect Barrier in Oaklands Project Objective: Protecting a Fruit Tree from Pests like Winter Moth Using Tanglefoot Insect […]
Comprehensive Tree Care for a Historic Estate in Rockland
Comprehensive Tree Care for a Historic Estate in Rockland, Victoria Project Objective: Comprehensive Tree Care for a Historic Estate in Rockland Location: Rockland, Victoria BC Date: Aug […]
Emergency Tree Removal After a Storm in Oak Bay, Victoria
Emergency Tree Removal After a Storm in Oak Bay, Victoria Project Objective: Emergency Tree Removal Following a Storm Location: Victoria, BC Date: July 2024 Tree Service Job […]
Structural Pruning for a Heritage Oak in Fairfield, Victoria
Structural Pruning for a Heritage Oak in Fairfield, Victoria Project Objective: Structural Pruning for a Heritage Oak Location: Victoria, BC Date: August 2024 Tree Service Job Overview […]
Tree Removal in Saanich
Tree Removal Project in Saanich Project Objective: Removal of hazardous tree Location: Saanich Date: April 2022 At this property the ATC team was called in to inspect […]

